Pages

Showing posts with label commercial soap. Show all posts
Showing posts with label commercial soap. Show all posts

Saturday, November 19, 2016

Dove Soap Vs. Earth N Moon Handmade Soap: What's in Your Soap


I know I've been away for a while, but I've been focusing on customers and new products for the past few months.
There is something that a lot of people who have never tried handmade soap always tell me:
"I can only use Dove soap." Well, do you know what's really in Dove soap?

I can not use Dove soap because it dries my skin out so bad. There's a reason for this.

Below, I have pulled the ingredients information from the plain Dove White Beauty Bar directly from the Dove website. I have never heard of most of these ingredients, but I am going to conduct a quick search and provide you with what the ingredients are. You can also view the ingredients and product information for yourself with the link below.

Dove White Beauty Bar Ingredients

Sodium Lauroyl Isethionate, Stearic Acid, Sodium Tallowate Or Sodium Palmitate, Lauric Acid, Sodium Isethionate, Water, Sodium Stearate, Cocamidopropyl Betaine, Sodium Cocoate Or Sodium Palm Kernelate, Fragrance, Sodium Chloride, Tetrasodium Edta, Tetrasodium Etidronate, Titanium Dioxide (Ci 77891).


I am conducting my chemical search through a database known as EWG.org. If you have never heard of them, they give a lot of valuable information on chemicals and toxicity levels that all of these commercial brands are using in YOUR soaps, makeups, lotions, cleaners, and detergents.
Now, let's break down these ingredients to show you what they are:

1. Sodium Lauroyl Isethionate - Although it is considered to have a low overall hazard rating, it is a chemical that is used as a surfactant or cleansing agent. There are currently 2 case studies on the toxicity level of this chemical. You should also know that use restrictions and limitations are required for this chemical. So, pretty much what this tells me is that at certain levels, this is considered safe in cosmetics and soaps. Why have it? Why do you need an added surfactant in your soap and cosmetics? 

2. Stearic Acid - Also considered to have a low overall hazard rating, Stearic Acid is a naturally occurring fatty acid that may be derived from agricultural and domestic animals. So, it's not vegan. Also, according to the Environment Canada Domestic Substance list, it is suspected to be an environmental hazard. Handmade lotion recipes often call for Stearic Acid and is used as a thickening agent.

3. Sodium Tallowate - Used as a surfactant and foam booster, Sodium Tallowate may also be derived from animals. It is also suspected to be an environmental hazard according to the Environment Canada Domestic Substance list. 

4. Lauric Acid - Considered a low overall hazard, and used as a surfactant, cleanser, and emulsifier. Cosmetic Ingredient Review Assessments have noted safety limits.

5. Sodium Isethionate - This ingredient is an organic salt that is used as an antistatic, cleanser, and hair and skin conditioner. There have also been data gap concerns as there have been 170 recorded case studies concerning the toxicity level of this ingredient. 

6. Water - Not hazardous.

7. Sodium Stearate - A naturally occurring fatty acid that is used as a cleansing agent and emulsifier. Low overall hazard rating. However, according to the Environment Canada Domestic Substance list, it is suspected to be an environmental hazard. 

8. Cocamidopropyl Betaine - So far, this is the ingredient that poses concern. It is moderately hazardous. This ingredient is an inorganic compound. It is a synthetic cleansing agent, skin and hair conditioner, and foam booster. This chemical has also registered on the scale for allergies, and it is also suspected to be an environmental hazard by the Environment Canada Domestic Substance list.  There are also data gaps in toxicity level information. Folks, you do NOT need foamy lather. Lather is not what determines clean. I'll get to this in a minute. 

9. Sodium Cocoate Or Sodium Palm Kernelate - Sodium Cocoate is a cleansing and emulsifying agent derived from coconut. Sodium Palm Kernelate is a cleansing, emulsifying, and viscosity controlling agent derived from palm. There are safety limitations on this ingredient.

10. Fragrance - Because we are not given the type of fragrance, ingredient information may or may not be invalid. Some fragrances register as high on the allergy scale while others do not. However, most of the people that I come across that say they can only use Dove mention that it is a fragrance-free soap which, in fact, it is not fragrance-free based on Dove's ingredients list from their website. Upon conducting research, it has been noted in some studies that fragrances in cosmetics may actually cause allergic reactions.

11. Sodium Chloride - An inorganic salt used as a flavoring and oral care agent as well as a viscosity increasing agent.

12. Tetrasodium Edta - Registering as a moderate hazard. According to the European Union Classification & Labeling and the Environment Canada Substance list, this ingredient has evidence as toxic and harmful notably in eyes. It is also a penetration and skin absorption enhancer according to Cosmetic Ingredient Review Assessments. It is a "chelating agent, used to sequester and decrease the reactivity of metal ions that may be present in a product." (ewg.org). Why do you need this in your soap? 

13. Tetrasodium Etidronate - Another chelating agent that is also used to stabilize emulsification and control viscosity. 

14. Titanium Dioxide - An inorganic compound used as a colorant. According to the California EPA, this ingredient is considered a possible human carcinogen only when inhaled or used in aerosols.This is the ingredient that gives the soap its white color. Some handmade soaps do contain Titanium Dioxide as a colorant as well.


Now, take a look at what Earth N Moon soaps are made of. We will compare our plainest bar of soap: Old Fashioned Lye Soap as well as our most popular Clear Complexion Soap

Clear Complexion Soap:

Coconut Oil, Canola Oil, Lard, Castor Oil, Avocado Oil, Rose Clay, Activated Charcoal, Litsea Essential Oil, Rosemary Essential Oil, Tea Tree Essential Oil, Water, Sodium Hydroxide.

1. Coconut Oil  -- Natural, food grade plant-based oil
2. Canola Oil  -- Natural, food grade plant-based oil
3. Lard  -- Natural, food grade oil which is rendered animal fat
4. Castor Oil  -- Natural, food grade plant-based oil
5. Avocado Oil  -- Natural, food grade plant-based oil
6. Rose Clay  -- Natural, cosmetic grade clay
7. Activated Charcoal  -- Natural, cosmetic grade powdered activated charcoal
8. Litsea Essential Oil  -- Natural, plant-based essential oil
9. Rosemary Essential Oil  -- Natural, plant-based essential oil
10. Tea Tree Essential Oil  -- Natural, plant-based essential oil
11. Water  -- Natural, non hazardous
12. Sodium Hydroxide  -- Inorganic compound used to soponify oils to make soap. Without it, there is no handmade soap. I use the food grade Sodium Hydroxide which is also used to make pretzels.

Old Fashioned Lye Soap:

Water, Lard, Sodium Hydroxide.

1. Water  -- Natural, non hazardous
2. Lard  -- Natural, food grade oil which is rendered animal fat
3. Sodium Hydroxide  -- Inorganic compound used to soponify oils to make soap. Without it, there is no handmade soap. I use the food grade Sodium Hydroxide which is also used to make pretzels.


So, based on the comparison, I did not see any natural oils in the Dove White Beauty Bar soap. In fact, Earth N Moon soaps contain more mild and safer ingredients than Dove soaps based on the ingredients comparison list. I saw more ingredients that were used as "cleansing agents" or "surfactants" or "emulsifiers". Let's also not forget the "chelating agent" ingredients. Why do you need that in soap? The point is you don't! I didn't even know what chelating was. I had to look it up. That should tell you that those ingredients do NOT belong in your soaps.
I know I have said it before, but you do NOT need foamy lather to get a good clean.

Lather ≠ Clean

Also, I would like to mention that while Sodium Hydroxide is caustic, there is none left in the final product because the oils have been soponified using Sodium Hydroxide. It's used in the process, but there is none left in the final product. In fact, the  PH level of Earth N Moon soaps register at a 7 which is considered mild. 

Plus, out of all of my customers, not one has said that the soap has made their skin dry. In fact, I've had customers tell me that the soap actually helped heal their skin especially the Psoriasis & Eczema soap as well as the Clear Complexion soap. I do not use commercial soaps anymore because they ALL dry my skin out and cause irritations. 

So, next time you reach for that Dove bar, ask yourself if you want to rub surfactants, emulsifiers, and chelating agents all over yourself. If you want a good bar of soap that doesn't cost an arm and a leg with natural ingredients, come see me. If you don't want animal byproducts in your soap, I offer vegan alternatives and can custom make you a soap. If you're allergic to a specific oil or ingredient, let me know. I will be happy to help find and make you a custom soap that does NOT contain harsh chemicals. 

Find me here:
Facebook
Email
Etsy

Thursday, August 18, 2016

Beneftis of Handmade Soap



So, I know I haven't been keeping up with my blog and for that, I apologize. However, I have been working diligently on some new soaps and getting set up to be in the new An Artisan's Emporium store as well as finishing out my associates degree in Accounting, all while taking care of my 2 year-old.

I've noticed here, lately, that a lot of big name soap and cosmetic companies are listing their products as "natural". I feel that while some companies are using truly natural products and are able to deem their products as all natural, there are other companies who are being less than honest about the products they are selling to the public.

To truly be an all natural product, all of the ingredients used within products should be of natural origin, meaning no synthetics. I can not technically claim that my soaps are "all natural" because they contain Sodium Hydroxide that was not produced in the traditional manner of running water through ashes. Now, if you make your lye in this manner, then it is not lab made and you could use it for natural soap-making. However, the commercially produced lye is lab made. The process uses water, sodium, and electricity. Here is more about the process https://dow-answer.custhelp.com/app/ans ... ng-process.

The saponification process is what happens when lye water mixes with oils to produce soap. Sodium Hydroxide, caustic soda, and lye are all the same thing. While lye is used in soap-making, there is no remaining lye left in the end product, which is soap. So, you are not washing with lye, you are washing with soap. Think of it in terms of cooking. When you are making bread and you use yeast as one of your ingredients, yeast was used to make the bread but the end result is bread. The yeast has been incorporated throughout in order to give you bread. It is what helps your bread rise. Sodium Hydroxide or lye is an important ingredient in making bar soap. Without it, you would just have a complete mess of oils, butters, and whatever else you used.

In fact, there are different grades of Sodium Hydroxide. There is the tech grade of Sodium Hydroxide that is used for making paper, rayon, industrial strength cleaners, etc and then there is the food grade of Sodium Hydroxide  that you can use in soap making, pretzel making, olives, soda breads, and other types of foods. Here is some more information on the differences between tech and food grade Sodium Hydroxide that may be helpful https://soapingwithstyle.wordpress.com/2014/06/21/technical-vs-food-grade-sodium-hydroxide/

I happen to use food grade Sodium Hydroxide. In fact, I have never used tech grade. Both are caustic and corrosive. So, which ever you choose, please be careful and take all precautionary measures to ensure you do not mishandle it and get burned.

Now that we know what Sodium Hydroxide is and the difference between food and tech grades, let's get down to the benefits of using handmade soaps.

Because most handmade soaps contain food grade ingredients such as oils, fats, and butters, the handmade soaps tend to be more mild than commercial soaps. Also, commercial soaps are considered detergents, not soap because of the chemicals used in the process. Handmade soaps typically do not contain chemicals and preservatives. In fact, real, handmade soap does not need a preservative at all. Although it may contain water and oil combinations, the ingredients are saponified, so , no need for a preservative. Your handmade soaps generally last about a year after being cured. Here is some additional information on the difference between commercial and handmade soap:
http://www.naturalnews.com/026110_soap_natural_clay.html

Now, just based on my experiences with soaps, I can tell you automatically the difference between handmade and commercial:


  1. Handmade soaps are typically softer than commercial soaps
  2. Handmade soaps should never be drying to the skin, no where near the way commercial soaps dry skin. Why is this? Commercial soaps, or should I say detergents, contain any of the following toxic ingredients: Sodium Laurel Sulfate (SLS)- A known carcinogenic and skin irritant (yuck!). Triclosan- A pesticide that is commonly used as an antibacterial agent. (what?!). Dioxane- Another carcinogenic that is derived from coconut which can be toxic to the brain, liver, and kidneys (this is getting scary, guys). Diethanolamine (DEA)- When combined with other chemicals and preservatives in soap, it creates NDEA which is a dangerous carcinogenic. According to Rain Victoria with Natural Essentials, "NDEA is a potent carcinogenic, and it is most strongly linked to the development of kidney and liver cancers. In addition, pregnant women should be especially cautious of DEA, as it is capable of interfering with your body’s ability to absorb a nutrient called choline. Unborn children need choline if their brains are to develop properly. All of these concerns are also likely to apply to triethanolamine (or TEA), which is a derivative of DEA." Formaldehyde- A known toxic ingredient that can lead to weakening of the immune system leaving the body less able to fight off infectious diseases.
  3. A lot of handmade soap makers use organic ingredients that contain no pesticides.
  4. You can really tell a difference in the texture and complexion of your skin when you used handmade soaps vs. commercial soaps. You don't get any flaking, peeling, burning, itching, rashes, dryness, and your skin actually is more hydrated, more radiant, softer, and smoother.
  5. Handmade soaps clean better. The commercial facial soaps used do not take makeup off as well as handmade facial soaps. Based on my experience, I still had to use a makeup remover with a commercial soap, but not with a handmade soap.


Handmade soaps normally do not contain these very toxic and potentially dangerous ingredients. This is some scary stuff. I would definitely urge anyone and everyone to look at the ingredients of not just their soap, but their skin care ingredients as well. It is definitely up to you what you choose to put on your skin. However, I just wanted to everyone to be aware of the chemicals that can be used in some commercially made soaps that are passed off as "natural".

Just try a handmade soap once and you'll definitely notice the difference. Plus, your skin will thank you. In a world that uses chemicals for everything, they definitely do not belong on your skin. It's not necessary and it can actually do more harm than good.


I'll be updating my blog more regularly now that I have some extra free time.
Until next time,

Cheers!
Kristine



Resources:

  • Natural News- http://www.naturalnews.com/026110_soap_natural_clay.html
  • Natural Essentials- http://www.botanicskinessentials.com/uncategorized/toxic-soap-ingredients/
  • Soaping With Style- https://soapingwithstyle.wordpress.com/2014/06/21/technical-vs-food-grade-sodium-hydroxide/